What a payroll service does, and who does it now
A full-service payroll company moves the money and files for you. With Selfroll you do those parts yourself, with exact steps. Here's the split.
| Task | Who | How |
|---|---|---|
| Work out gross pay, withholding and net pay | Selfroll | Run payroll: type it in plain English or use the form. |
| Pay employees by direct deposit | You | Send take-home pay from your business account in your bank's app (transfer, ACH, or your bank's direct deposit). Selfroll gives the amount. |
| Deposit federal payroll taxes (941) | You | EFTPS, by the date Selfroll shows. Monthly: the 15th of the next month. |
| Deposit federal unemployment tax (940) | You | EFTPS, only when more than $500 is owed; otherwise pay with Form 940. |
| Pay state income tax withholding | You | Your state's tax website, on the schedule the state assigns you. Selfroll gives the amount and the link. (Nine states have no income tax on wages.) |
| Pay state unemployment tax | You | Your state's unemployment tax portal, with the quarterly wage report. |
| File Form 941 each quarter | Selfroll prepares, you file | Selfroll fills a draft. You check, sign, and mail it or e-file it with software you choose. |
| File the state withholding return | Selfroll prepares, you file | Selfroll gives the wages and tax withheld for the period. You file on your state's tax website. |
| File the state unemployment report | Selfroll prepares, you file | Selfroll lists each person's total and taxable wages. You enter them in your state's portal. |
| File Form 940 each year | Selfroll prepares, you file | Selfroll fills a draft. You check, sign, and file. |
| Give employees W-2s; file W-2s and W-3 with SSA | Selfroll prepares, you file | Selfroll fills employee copies and totals. You hand them out and type them into SSA Business Services Online. |
| File state W-2s and the annual reconciliation | Selfroll prepares, you file | Selfroll gives the totals. You upload or type them on your state's tax website (many states want them by January 31). |
| Track every deadline | Selfroll | Calendar page, with an .ics file for Google, Apple, or Outlook calendars. |
| Pay stubs | Selfroll | Each paycheck page prints a stub. |
| Pay penalties for its own mistakes (tax guarantee) | You | No guarantee here. Late or wrong deposits are your penalties, so act on the reminders. |
| Talk to the IRS or state for you | You | Selfroll isn't your agent. You handle notices; a CPA can help. |
| New-hire reporting, I-9s, workers' comp | You | Report new hires to your state (Selfroll links each state's new-hire site) and keep I-9s on file. Workers' comp isn't covered. |
One-time setup
Do these before your first payday. Track them on the setup checklist.
- Have an EIN
Your S corp's federal employer ID. Free from the IRS. Open
- Enroll in EFTPS
eftps.gov, Enrollment, Business. Enter your EIN, business details and bank account. The IRS says enrollment can take up to five business days to process, then the PIN comes by mail, so do this well before your first payday. Open
- Register for SSA Business Services Online
Sign in with Login.gov or ID.me. Under SSA's new process (effective November 7, 2026), your company's Responsible Entity Officer registers the EIN and SSA mails a registration code that can take 15 to 20 days, so register well before January. Open
- Register a state withholding account
With the tax agency in the state where your employees work, unless it's one of the nine states with no income tax on wages. You'll use it for payments, returns, and the year-end W-2 upload. The states page links each agency. Open
- Open a state unemployment tax account
Every state has one, including states with no income tax. The state sends your rate; new employers usually start at a set new-employer rate. Also report each new hire to the state. Open
- Collect forms from each employee
Federal W-4, your state's withholding certificate (if it has one), and I-9. Enter the choices in Setup. Open
- Set up payments in your bank
Add each employee's account as a payee for transfers or ACH, from your business account.
- Add the deadlines to your calendar
Calendar page, Download .ics, then import it.
Switching from a payroll service mid-year
Enter the year-to-date wages already paid so the Social Security and unemployment wage limits stay right, and ask your old provider for its quarter-to-date filings. Selfroll's numbers start from the first paycheck you run here. For a mid-quarter switch the old provider's 941 and yours won't add up automatically, so plan the switch at the start of a quarter. More in Switching from Gusto or OnPay to do-it-yourself payroll.
General information, not tax or legal advice. See the Terms.